Set in the world of Toy Story, the movie opens with a lovable loser type guy who has a collection of sex dolls of various types and quality. Think Lars and the Real Girl but more. His best friend comes over and they have a heart to heart about how he needs to get over this and find a real woman. He agrees and boxes up the dolls putting them in the basement across the room from a large old fashioned furnace.

After a montage of horrible dates, he brings a woman home from the bars to his place. They drunkenly get into bed before he admits that she’s the first real woman he’s been with since his wife died. She gets weirded out and says she remembered there’s an early meeting she has to be at work for and leaves him crying in bed. As she tries to put on her shoes near the front door a plastic bag is slipped over her head.

The next day he’s complaining to his friend about how much of a loser he is. He brings the dolls back out of the boxes and talks to them like they’re real.

His friend comes over with his wife and together they box up the dolls and throw them in the trash. All except one which is kept for sentimental reasons.

His friend’s wife sets him up on a blind date with her sister. As his car leaves we see that all the boxes are missing from the alleyway. Two of the boxes are back in the house in the basement.

A third has been taken from the alley and is in the possession of a BDSM enthusiast who is pretending to torture it. The doll comes to life and kills him.

The main character brings his blind date home. They’ve bonded over her being a widow as well. As they make their way to the bedroom she spots the doll he kept sitting on a chair in the hallway. He doesn’t remember putting it there, but explains that he had some strange ways of coping with the loss. She’s understanding and even comments that the doll is pretty with such lifelike eyes. He says he bought it because it looked so much like his dead wife, but he thinks he’s over that part of the grieving process now. He and the date kiss as the bedroom door closes.

They have sex and the date goes to use the bathroom down the hall after. She looks in the mirror and sees the dolls standing behind her, one of them holding a thick plastic bag open in the air. The two blow-up dolls are stabbed with scissors and slowly deflate as they pin the date against the wall, but the scissors have no effect on the main silicon doll. As the doll overpowers the date and begins to tighten the bag over her head the main character rescues her by throwing the doll down the stairs.

They quickly dress and try to flee the house, only to fall on a saran wrap tripwire near the back door and be captured by the doll.

They wake up in the basement with their bodies shrink-wrapped to a board on the floor. To their left and right are the earlier victims, also shrink wrapped but with grotesquely sexual makeup smeared on their faces.

“I’m going to make you one of us.” hisses the main doll as she slips the plastic bag over the dates head again.

The date gasps for air while the main doll explains that the dolls loved the main character and if killing him is the only way they can stay together forever then so be it.

The main character manages to slip his legs free of the shrink wrap and charges at the main doll. Together they crash onto the furnace which makes a sizzling noise as the heat begins to melt the doll’s face and torso dripping molten rubber onto the main character. The main character collapses backward and worms his way across the floor to pull the bag from his dates head with his teeth.

When he turns back the main doll is gone and the basement door is ajar.