Having sex with a virgin in the backseat of my car once, she asked me to stick it in her butt. I thought it would take a while to gape it out, as her vagina was tight as hell. Yet upon insertion into the anus, it consumed my cock like a black hole. I was horrified and asked her why her butt hole was soooo loose. Turns out she’d been dildoing her anus for years…true story.