Most songs are about having fun with friends or on a date in the middle of nowhere and a large majority of reddit users can’t relate to the topics. It’s not complex music, but it’s normally happy and fun to dance to. The stereotype of my dog died has not been popular for 20+ years. Luke Bryant, Jason Aldean, Luke combs and Kenny chesney don’t write songs to be listened to with headphones on alone. A majority of reddit users are introverted people who live in cities and have no frame of reference for swimming in a river or hanging out at a bonfire